FORUM, Forum Discussion, Forum Gratuit, Nom de domaine, Nom de domaine gratuit, Redirection gratuite,

Forum Flowers of India - The waterhole of flower lovers. Administrators :tabish, Dinesh Valke
Forum Flowers of India - The waterhole of flower lovers.
Not logged | Login
Online:2 guests are browsing the forum
Register Register | Profile Profile | Private messages Private messages | Search Search | Online Online | Help Help | Create a free blog

forum Forum index forumFlower ID forumImpatiens lawii

Author : Topic: Impatiens lawii  Bottom
 tabish
 admin
 Posts : 369
 Let us learn to dream gentlemen,
and then we may find the truth...
 tabish
  Posted 29/04/2008 03:01:12 AM
Send a private message to tabish
Attention Dinesh.
Jyosna Dessai, who works on Balsams, claims that
Many people including botanists identify the long leaved species of Balsam as Impatiens lawii but this is not true. Infact this species is small in size with small ovate leaves that are crowded at the apex.

I first checked out the picture of the specimen which we have used

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2274/1651861612_7415a89c1f.jpg?v=0


On zoom into the flower, I could a see a small incurved spur. However in I. lawii, the spur is supposed to be absent.

Jyosna suggests that the species which we have (mis)identified as I. lawii, could be either I. tomentosa or I. rupicola.
I could find the following identification keys for the two.
I. tomentosa: anterior sepal hooded, with a short spur inflated at the point
I. rupicola: Spur short; incurved; flowers small, rose or rose - purple

As I could not see any inflation in the spur, I would think our species could be I. rupicola.

Real Impatiens lawii

Jyosna says that our unidentified flower pka06 is the real I. lawii. Here is the picture for comparison:
http://www.flowersofindia.net/catalog/Unidentified/slides/pka06.jpg

My reference Handbook of the Indian
Flora
, by Heber Drury, describes the leaves of I.lawii as
shortly oblong, obtuse at the base, sessile, the upper ones smaller, cordate, stem-clasping, remotely serrated, roughish above.
Indeed the upper leaves are short and heart-shaped. If this descrïption is correct, then Ingalhalikar's descrïption, although not incorrect, leaves room for confusion.

Comments solicited.

 Dinesh Valke
 admin
 Posts : 509
  Posted 29/04/2008 11:51:49 PM
Send a private message to Dinesh Valke
I am very glad that there has been a review ... very fortunate to get misidentified species set straight.

Many thanks to Jyosna.

 Dinesh Valke
 admin
 Posts : 509
  Posted 29/04/2008 11:53:16 PM
Send a private message to Dinesh Valke
Thanks to you too, Tabish :-)


forum Forum index forumFlower ID forumImpatiens lawii
top
Go to :
  Add a quick reply

Add a quick reply